Skip to content

# Category: Development

## Observations on the hashicorp/raft library, and notes on RDBMS

Development MySQL freno golang MySQL orchestrator raft June 20, 2017

The hashicorp/raft library is a Go library to provide consensus via Raft protocol implementation. It is the underlying library behind Hashicorp’s Consul.

I’ve had the opportunity to work with this library a couple projects, namely freno and orchestrator. Here are a few observations on working with this library:

- TL;DR on Raft: a group communication protocol; multiple nodes communicate, elect a leader. A leader leads a consensus (any subgroup of more than half the nodes of the original group, or hopefully all of them). Nodes may leave and rejoin, and will remain consistent with consensus.
- The hashicorp/raft library is an implementation of the Raft protocol. There are other implementations, and different implementations support different features.
- The most basic premise is leader election. This is pretty straightforward to implement; you set up nodes to communicate to each other, and they elect a leader. You may query for the leader identity via Leader(), VerifyLeader(), or observing LeaderCh.
- You have no control over the identity of the leader. You cannot “prefer” one node to be the leader. You cannot grab leadership from an elected leader, and you cannot demote a leader unless by killing it.
- The next premise is gossip, sending messages between the raft nodes. With `hashicorp/raft`, only the leader may send messages to the group. This is done via the Apply() function.
- Messages are nothing but blobs. Your app encodes the messages into `[]byte` and ships it via raft. Receiving ends need to decode the bytes into a meaningful message.
- You will check the result of Apply(), an ApplyFuture. The call to Error() will wait for consensus.
- Just what is a message consensus? It’s a guarantee that the consensus of nodes has received and registered the message.
- Messages form the raft log.
- Messages are guaranteed to be handled in-order across all nodes.
- The leader is satisfied when the followers receive the messages/log, but it cares not for their interpretation of the log.
- The leader does not collect the output, or return value, of the followers applying of the log.
- Consequently, your followers may not abort the message. They may not cast an opinion. They must adhere to the instruction received from the leader.
- `hashicorp/raft` uses either an LMDB-based store or BoltDB for persisting your messages. Both are transactional stores.
- Messages are expected to be idempotent: a node that, say, happens to restart, will request to join back the consensus (or to form a consensus with some other node). To do that, it will have to reapply historical messages that it may have applied in the past.
- Number of messages (log entries) will grow infinitely. Snapshots are taken so as to truncate the log history. You will implement the snapshot dump & load.
- A snapshot includes the log index up to which it covers.
- Upon startup, your node will look for the most recent snapshot. It will read it, then resume replication from the aforementioned log index.
- `hashicorp/raft` provides a file-system based snapshot implementation.

One of my use cases is completely satisfied with the existing implementations of `BoltDB` and of the filesystem snapshot.

However in another (`orchestrator`), my app stores its state in a relational backend. To that effect, I’ve modified the logstore and snapshot store. I’m using either MySQL or `sqlite` as backend stores for my app. How does that affect my `raft` use? Continue reading » “Observations on the hashicorp/raft library, and notes on RDBMS”

## Forking Golang repositories on GitHub and managing the import path

Development GitHub golang November 23, 2015November 24, 2015

Problem: there’s an awesome Golang project on GitHub which you want to fork. You want to develop & collaborate on that fork, but the golang import path, in your source code, still references the original path, breaking everything.

A couple solutions offered below. First, though, let’s get some names.

### A sample case, the problem at hand

There’s an awesome tool on http://github.com/awsome-org/tool. You successfully fork it onto http://github.com/awesome-you/tool.

You want to collaborate on http://github.com/awesome-you/tool; you wish to pull, commit & push. Maybe you want to send pull requests to the origin.

The following is commonly found throughout .go files in the repository:

>     import (
>         "github.com/awesome-org/tool/config"
>         "github.com/awesome-org/tool/driver"
>         "github.com/awesome-org/tool/net"
>         "github.com/awesome-org/tool/util"
>     )

If you:

>     go get http://github.com/awesome-you/tool

golang creates your $GOPATH/src/github.com/awesome-you/tool/, which is awesome. However, as you resolve dependencies via

>     cd $GOPATH/src/github.com/awesome-you/tool/ ; go get ./...

golang digs into the source code, finds references to github.com/awesome-org/tool/config, github.com/awesome-org/tool/driver etc, and fetches those from http://github.com/awsome-org/tool and onto $GOPATH/src/github.com/awesome-org/tool/, which is not awesome. You actually have two copies of the code, one from your fork, one from the origin, and your own fork will be largely ignored as it mostly points back to the origin.

### A bad solution

The dirty, bad solution would be for you to go over the source code and replace “github.com/awesome-org/tool” entries with “github.com/awesome-you/tool”. It is bad for two reasons:

- You will not be able to further pull changes from upstream
- You will not be able to pull-request and push your own changes upstream

Continue reading » “Forking Golang repositories on GitHub and managing the import path”

## zookeepercli: lightweight, powerful, controlled command line client for ZooKeeper

Development Linux command line go Open Source ZooKeeper September 17, 2014

I’m happy to announce the availability of zookeepercli: a lightweight, simple, fast and controlled command line client for ZooKeeper.

zookeepercli allows for:

- Basic CRUD-like operations: `create`, `set`, `delete`, `exists`, `get`, `ls` (aka `children`).
- Extended operations: `lsr` (ls recursive), `creater` (create recursively)
- Well formatted and controlled output: supporting either `txt` or `json` format
- Single, no-dependencies binary file, based on a native Go ZooKeeper library by github.com/samuel/go-zookeeper (LICENSE)

I was dissatisfied with existing command line access to ZooKeeper. Uncontrolled and noisy output as well as large footprint were among the reasons. zookeepercli overcomes the above and provides with often required powers.

Usage samples:

>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c create /demo_only "path placeholder"
>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c create /demo_only/key1 "value1"
>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c create /demo_only/key2 "value2"
>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c create /demo_only/key3 "value3"

>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c ls /demo_only
>     key3
>     key2
>     key1

>     # Same as above, JSON format output:
>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 --format=json -c ls /demo_only
>     ["key3","key2","key1"]

>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c delete /demo_only/key1
>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c delete /demo_only/key2
>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c delete /demo_only/key3
>     $ zookeepercli --servers srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c delete /demo_only

>     # Create a path recursively (auto-generate parent directories if not exist):
>     $ zookeepercli --servers=srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c creater "/demo_only/child/key1" "val1"
>     $ zookeepercli --servers=srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c creater "/demo_only/child/key2" "val2"

>     $ zookeepercli --servers=srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c get "/demo_only/child/key1"
>     val1

>     # This path was auto generated due to recursive create:
>     $ zookeepercli --servers=srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c get "/demo_only"
>     zookeepercli auto-generated

>     # ls recursively a path and all sub children:
>     $ zookeepercli --servers=srv-1,srv-2,srv-3 -c lsr "/demo_only"
>     child
>     child/key1
>     child/key2

zookeepercli is released as open source by Outbrain under the Apache 2.0 license.

Quick links:

- Project page
- Pre-built binaries for download
- License

## Documentation in SQL: CALL for help()

Development MySQL common_schema documentation mycheckpoint Open Source openark kit Stored routines January 11, 2012

Documentation is an important part of any project. On the projects I maintain I put a lot of effort on documentation, and, frankly, the majority of time spent on my projects is on documentation.

The matter of keeping the documentation faithful is a topic of interest. I’d like to outline a few documentation bundling possibilities, and the present the coming new documentation method for common_schema. I’ll talk about any bundling that is NOT man pages.

#### High level: web docs

This is the initial method of documentation I used for openark kit and mycheckpoint. It’s still valid for mycheckpoint. Documentation is web-based. You need Internet access to read it. It’s in HTML format.

Well, not exactly HTML format: I wrote it in WordPress. Yes, it’s HTML, but there’s a lot of noise around (theme, menus, etc.) which is not strictly part of the documentation.

While this is perhaps the easiest way to go, here’s a few drawbacks: Continue reading » “Documentation in SQL: CALL for help()”

## More MySQL foreach()

Development MySQL common_schema Hack INFORMATION_SCHEMA Open Source scripts SQL December 2, 2011

In my previous post I’ve shown several generic use cases for foreach(), a new scripting functionality introduced in common_schema.

In this part I present DBA’s handy syntax for schema and table operations and maintenance.

Confession: while I love INFORMATION_SCHEMA‘s power, I just hate writing queries against it. It’s just so much typing! Just getting the list of tables in a schema makes for this heavy duty query:

>     SELECT TABLE_NAME FROM INFORMATION_SCHEMA.TABLES WHERE TABLE_SCHEMA='sakila' AND TABLE_TYPE='BASE TABLE';

When a join is involved this really becomes a nightmare. I think it’s cumbersome, and as result, many do not remember the names and meaning of columns, making for “oh, I need to read the manual all over again just to get that query right”. Anyway, that’s my opinion.

A SHOW TABLES statement is easier to type, but cannot be integrated into a SELECT query (though we have a partial solution for that, too), and besides, when filtering out the views, the SHOW statement becomes almost as cumbersome as the one on INFORMATION_SCHEMA.

Which is why foreach() offers handy shortcuts to common iterations on schemata and tables, as follows:

#### Use case: iterate all databases

>     call foreach('schema', 'CREATE TABLE ${schema}.event(event_id INT, msg VARCHAR(128))');

In the above we execute a query on each database. Hmmm, maybe not such a good idea to perform this operation on all databases? Let’s filter them:

#### Use case: iterate databases by name match

>     call foreach('schema like wordpress_%', 'ALTER TABLE ${schema}.wp_posts MODIFY COLUMN comment_author VARCHAR(96) NOT NULL');

The above will only iterate my WordPress databases (I have several of these), performing an ALTER on wp_posts for each of those databases. Continue reading » “More MySQL foreach()”

## Test-driven SQL development

Development MySQL Ant common_schema Development Linux scripts Stored routines October 20, 2011

I’m having a lot of fun writing common_schema, an SQL project which includes views, tables and stored routines.

As the project grows (and it’s taking some interesting directions, in my opinion) more dependencies are being introduced, and a change to one routine or view may affect many others. This is why I’ve turned the development on common_schema to be test driven.

Now, just how do you test drive an SQL project?

Well, much like the way you test any other project in your favorite programming language. If its functions you’re testing, that’s all too familiar: functions get some input and provide some output. Hmmm, they might be changing SQL data during that time. With procedures it’s slightly more complex, since they do not directly return output but result sets.

Here’s the testing scheme I use: Continue reading » “Test-driven SQL development”

## oak-hook-general-log: your poor man’s Query Analyzer

Development MySQL Analysis logs Open Source openark kit python scripts December 15, 2010

The latest release of openark kit introduces oak-hook-general-log, a handy tool which allows for some analysis of executing queries.

Initially I just intended for the tool to be able to dump the general log to standard output, from any machine capable to connect to MySQL. Quick enough, I realized the power it brings.

With this tool, one can dump to standard output all queries using temporary tables; or using a specific index; or doing a full index scan; or just follow up on connections; or… For example, the following execution will only log queries which make for filesort:

>     oak-hook-general-log --user=root --host=localhost --password=123456 --filter-explain-filesort

#### The problem with using the standard logs

So you have the general log, which you don’t often enable, since it tends to grow huge within moments. You then have the slow log. Slow log is great, and is among the top tools for MySQL diagnosis.

The slow log allows for log-queries-not-using-indexes, which is yet another nice feature. Not only should you log any query running for over X seconds, but also log any query which does not use an index.

Wait. This logs all single-row tables (no single row table will use an index), as well as very small tables (a common 20 rows lookup table will most often be scanned). These are OK scans. This makes for some noise in the slow log.

And how about queries which do use an index, but do so poorly? They use an index, but retrieve some 12,500,000 rows, using temporary table & filesort?

#### What oak-hook-general-log does for you

This tool streams out the general log, and filters out queries based on their role or on their execution plan.

To work at all, it must enable the general log. Moreover, it directs the general log to log table. Mind that this makes for a performance impact, which is why the tool auto-terminates and restores original log settings (default is 1 minute, configurable). It’s really not a tool you should keep running for days. But during the few moments it runs, it will:

- Routinely rotate the mysql.general_log table so that it doesn’t fill up
- Examine entries found in the general log
- Cross reference entries to the PROCESSLIST so as to deduce database context (bug #52554)
- If required and appropriate, evaluate a query’s execution plan
- Decide whether to dump each entry based on filtering rules

#### Filtering rules

Filtering rules are passed as command line options. At current, only one filtering rule applies (if more than one specified only one is used, so no point in passing more than one). Some of the rules are: Continue reading » “oak-hook-general-log: your poor man’s Query Analyzer”

## openark-kit (rev. 170): new tools, new functionality

Development MySQL Analysis Open Source openark kit python Replication scripts December 15, 2010December 15, 2010

I’m pleased to announce a new release of the openark kit. There’s a lot of new functionality inside; following is a brief overview.

The openark kit is a set of utilities for MySQL. They solve everyday maintenance tasks, which may be complicated or time consuming to work by hand.

It’s been a while since the last announced release. Most of my attention was on mycheckpoint, building new features, writing documentation etc. However my own use of openark kit has only increased in the past few months, and there’s new useful solutions to common problems that have been developed.

I’ve used and improved many tools over this time, but doing the final cut, along with proper documentation, took some time. Anyway, here are the highlights:

#### New tool: oak-hook-general-log

oak-hook-general-log hooks up a MySQL server and dumps the general log based on filtering rules, applying to query role or execution plan. It is possible to only dump connect/disconnect entries, queries which make a full table scan, or use temporary tables, or scan more than X number of rows, or…

I’ll write more on this tool shortly.

#### New tool: oak-prepare-shutdown

This tool makes for an orderly and faster shutdown by safely stopping replication, and flushing InnoDB pages to disk prior to shutting down (keeping server available for connections even while attempting to flush dirty pages to disk). A typical use case would be:

>     oak-prepare-shutdown --user=root --ask-pass --socket=/tmp/mysql.sock && /etc/init.d/mysql stop

#### New tool: oak-repeat query

oak-repeat-query repeats executing a given query until some condition holds. The condition can be:

- Number of given iterations has been reached
- Given time has elapsed
- No rows have been affected by query

The tool comes in handy for cleanup jobs, warming up caches, etc. Continue reading » “openark-kit (rev. 170): new tools, new functionality”

## Thoughts and ideas for Online Schema Change

Development MySQL Development Indexing INFORMATION_SCHEMA InnoDB Open Source openark kit Opinions python Schema scripts Triggers October 7, 2010October 7, 2010

Here’s a few thoughts on current status and further possibilities for Facebook’s Online Schema Change (OSC) tool. I’ve had these thoughts for months now, pondering over improving oak-online-alter-table but haven’t got around to implement them nor even write them down. Better late than never.

The tool has some limitations. Some cannot be lifted, some could. Quoting from the announcement and looking at the code, I add a few comments. I conclude with a general opinion on the tool’s abilities.

#### “The original table must have PK. Otherwise an error is returned.”

This restriction could be lifted: it’s enough that the table has a UNIQUE KEY. My original oak-online-alter-table handled that particular case. As far as I see from their code, the Facebook code would work just as well with any unique key.

However, this restriction is of no real interest. As we’re mostly interested in InnoDB tables, and since any InnoDB table should have a PRIMARY KEY, we shouldn’t care too much.

#### “No foreign keys should exist. Otherwise an error is returned.”

Tricky stuff. With oak-online-alter-table, changes to the original table were immediately reflected in the ghost table. With InnoDB tables, that meant same transaction. And although I never got to update the text and code, there shouldn’t be a reason for not using child-side foreign keys (the child-side is the table on which the FK constraint is defined).

The Facebook patch works differently: it captures changes and writes them to a delta table, to be later (asynchronously) analyzed and make for a replay of actions on the ghost table. Continue reading » “Thoughts and ideas for Online Schema Change”

## Table refactoring & application version upgrades, Part II

Development MySQL Development Indexing Replication August 12, 2010August 12, 2010

Continuing Table refactoring & application version upgrades, Part I, we now discuss code & database upgrades which require DROP operations. As before, we break apart the upgrade process into sequential steps, each involving either the application or the database, but not both.

As I’ll show, DROP operations are significantly simpler than creation operations. Interestingly, it’s the same as in life.

#### DROP COLUMN

A column turns to be redundant, unused. Before it is dropped from the database, we must ensure no one is using it anymore. The steps are:

1. App: V1 -> V2. Remove all references to column; make sure no queries use said column.
2. DB: V1 -> V2 (possibly failover from M1 to M2), change is DROP COLUMN.

#### DROP INDEX

A possibly simpler case here. Why would you drop an index? Is it because you found out you never use it anymore? Then all you have to do is just drop it.

Or perhaps you don’t need the functionality the index supports anymore? Then first drop the functionality:

1. (optional) App: V1 -> V2. Discard using functionality which relies on index.
2. DB: V1 -> V2 (possibly failover from M1 to M2), change is DROP INDEX. Check out InnoDB Plugin here. Continue reading » “Table refactoring & application version upgrades, Part II”