Year: 2010

Table refactoring & application version upgrades, Part I

Development MySQL

A developer’s major concern is: How do I do application & database upgrades with minimal downtime? How do I synchronize between a DB’s version upgrade and an application’s version upgrade?

I will break down the discussion into types of database refactoring operations, and I will limit to single table refactoring. The discussion will try to understand the need for refactoring and will dictate the steps towards a successful upgrade.

Reader prerequisites

I will assume MySQL to be the underlying database. To take a major component out of the equation: we may need to deal with very large tables, for which an ALTER command may take long hours. I will assume familiarity with Master-Master (Active-Passive) replication, with possible use of MMM for MySQL. When I describe “Failover from M1 to M2“, I mean “Make the ALTER changes on M2 (passive), then switch your application from M1 to M2 (change of IPs, VIP, etc.), promoting M2 to active position, then apply same changes on M1 (now passive) or completely rebuild it”.

Phew, a one sentence description of M-M usage…

I also assume the reader’s understanding that a table’s schema can be different on master & slave, which is the basis for the “use replication for refactoring” trick. But it cannot be too different, or, to be precise, the two schemata must both support the ongoing queries for the table.

A full discussion of the above is beyond the scope of this post.

Types of refactoring needs

As I limit this discussion to single table refactoring,we can look at major refactoring operations and their impact on application & upgrades. We will discuss ADD/DROP COLUMN, ADD/DROP INDEX, ADD/DROP UNIQUE INDEX, ADD/DROP FOREIGN KEY, ADD/DROP TABLE.

We will assume the database and application are both in Version #1 (V1), and need to be upgraded to V2 or greater. Continue reading » “Table refactoring & application version upgrades, Part I”

Tips for taking MySQL backups using LVM

MySQL

LVM uses copy-on-write to implement snapshots. Whenever you’re writing data to some page, LVM copies the original page (the way it looked like when the snapshot was taken) to the snapshot volume. The snapshot volume must be large enough to accommodate all pages written to for the duration of the snapshot’s lifetime. In other words, you must be able to copy the data somewhere outside (tape, NFS, rsync, etc.) in less time than it would take for the snapshot to fill up.

While LVM allows for hot backups of MySQL, it still poses an impact on the disks. An LVM snapshot backup may not go unnoticed by the MySQL users.

Some general guidelines for making life easier with LVM backups follow.

Lighter, longer snapshots

If you’re confident that you have enough space on your snapshot volume, you may take the opportunity to make for a longer backup time. Why? Because you would then be able to reduce the stress from the file system. Use ionice when copying your data from the snapshot volume:

ionice -c 2 cp -R /mnt/mysql_snapshot /mnt/backup/daily/20100719/

[Update: this is only on the cfq I/O scheduler; thanks, Vojtech]

Are you running out of space?

Monitor snapshot’s allocated size: if there’s just one snapshot, do it like this: Continue reading » “Tips for taking MySQL backups using LVM”

SQL trick: overcoming GROUP_CONCAT limitation in special cases

MySQL

In Verifying GROUP_CONCAT limit without using variables, I have presented a test to verify if group_concat_max_len is sufficient for known limitations. I will follow the path where I assume I cannot control group_concat_max_len, not even in session scope, and show an SQL solution, dirty as it is, to overcome the GROUP_CONCAT limitation, under certain conditions.

Sheeri rightfully asks why I wouldn’t just set group_concat_max_len in session scope. The particular case I have is that I’m providing a VIEW definition. I’d like users to “install” that view, i.e. to CREATE it on their database. The VIEW does some logic, and uses GROUP_CONCAT to implement that logic.

Now, I have no control on the DBA or developer who created the view. The creation of the view has nothing to do with the group_concat_max_len setting on her database instance.

An example

OK, apologies aside. Using the sakila database, I execute:

mysql> SELECT GROUP_CONCAT(last_name) FROM actor \G
*************************** 1. row ***************************
GROUP_CONCAT(last_name): AKROYD,AKROYD,AKROYD,ALLEN,ALLEN,ALLEN,ASTAIRE,BACALL,BAILEY,BAILEY,BALE,BALL,BARRYMORE,BASINGER,BENING,BENING,BERGEN,BERGMAN,BERRY,BERRY,BERRY,BIRCH,BLOOM,BOLGER,BOLGER,BRIDGES,BRODY,BRODY,BULLOCK,CAGE,CAGE,CARREY,CHAPLIN,CHASE,CHASE,CLOSE,COSTNER,CRAWFORD,CRAWFORD,CRONYN,CRONYN,CROWE,CRUISE,CRUZ,DAMON,DAVIS,DAVIS,DAVIS,DAY-LEWIS,DEAN,DEAN,DEE,DEE,DEGENERES,DEGENERES,DEGENERES,DENCH,DENCH,DEPP,DEPP,DERN,DREYFUSS,DUKAKIS,DUKAKIS,DUNST,FAWCETT,FAWCETT,GABLE,GARLAND,GARLAND,GARLAND,GIBSON,GOLDBERG,GOODING,GOODING,GRANT,GUINESS,GUINESS,GUINESS,HACKMAN,HACKMAN,HARRIS,HARRIS,HARRIS,HAWKE,HESTON,HOFFMAN,HOFFMAN,HOFFMAN,HOPE,HOPKINS,HOPKINS,HOPKINS,HOPPER,HOPPER,HUDSON,HUNT,HURT,JACKMAN,JACKMAN,JOHANSSON,JOHANSSON,JOHANSSON,JOLIE,JOVOVICH,KEITEL,KEITEL,KEITEL,KILMER,KILMER,KILMER,KILMER,KILMER,LEIGH,LOLLOBRIGIDA,MALDEN,MANSFIELD,MARX,MCCONAUGHEY,MCCONAUGHEY,MCDORMAND,MCKELLEN,MCKELLEN,MCQUEEN,MCQUEEN,MIRANDA,MONROE,MONROE,MOSTEL,MOSTEL,NEESON,NEESON,NICHOLSON,NOLTE,NOLTE,NOLTE,NOLTE,OLIVIER,OLIVIER,PALTROW,PALTROW,P
1 row in set, 1 warning (0.00 sec)

mysql> SHOW WARNINGS;
+---------+------+--------------------------------------+
| Level   | Code | Message                              |
+---------+------+--------------------------------------+
| Warning | 1260 | 1 line(s) were cut by GROUP_CONCAT() |
+---------+------+--------------------------------------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

Continue reading » “SQL trick: overcoming GROUP_CONCAT limitation in special cases”

mycheckpoint (rev. 170): improved custom queries; local charting; page/swap I/O monitoring; improved HTML reports

MySQL

Revision 170 of mycheckpoint, a MySQL monitoring solution, has been released. New and updated in this revision:

  • Improved custom queries: lifting of limitations from previous, introductory revision; better HTML presentation
  • Local, inline charting: no rendering of Google Charts, unless explicitly requested. All charts are now rendered locally using JavaScript. No data is now sent over the network.
  • Page/Swap I/O monitoring: now monitoring for page ins and outs, swap ins and outs (Linux only).
  • Improved HTML reports: several improvements on presentation (see sample, more follow).

Improved custom queries

Some limitations, introduced in revision 132, are now lifted. New features are introduced.

  • There is now no limit to the number of custom queries (well, an INT limit).
  • In fact, the data tables adjust themselves to the existing custom queries in the form of auto-deploy: once a new custom query is added or an old one removed, mycheckpoint will add or remove the relevant columns from the data tables.
  • The chart_order column is now utilized: HTML reports which include custom query charts now order those charts according to chart_order values. This makes for nicer reports.
  • The standard HTML brief report (SELECT html FROM sv_report_html_brief) now automatically includes all custom charts. The HTML brief report is the report one usually wants to look at: it provides with the latest 24 hours metrics for selected values. It now becomes a centralized place for all that is interesting in the past 24 hours.
  • Custom queries are now allowed to return NULL, treated as a missing value. This is a bugfix from previous revisions.

Local charting

Motivation for local charting is clear: no one likes having their data being sent over the network. And no one likes Google to know about their DML values.

I’ve been playing around with quite a few charting solutions, and have gone into depths with two of them, adding and rewriting quite a lot of code. Eventually, I settled on my very own rendering. Here’s what I’ve seen & tested: Continue reading » “mycheckpoint (rev. 170): improved custom queries; local charting; page/swap I/O monitoring; improved HTML reports”

Implicit casting you don’t want to see around

MySQL

In Beware of implicit casting, I have outlined the dangers of implicit casting. Here’s a few more real-world examples I have tackled:

Number-String comparisons

Much like in programming languages, implicit casting is made to numbers when at least one of the arguments is a number. Thus:

mysql> SELECT 3 = '3.0';
+-----------+
| 3 = '3.0' |
+-----------+
|         1 |
+-----------+
1 row in set (0.00 sec)

mysql> SELECT '3' = '3.0';
+-------------+
| '3' = '3.0' |
+-------------+
|           0 |
+-------------+

The second query consists of pure strings comparison. It has no way to determine that number comparison should be made.

Direct DATE arithmetics

The first query seems to work, but is completely incorrect. The second explains why. The third is a total mess. Continue reading » “Implicit casting you don’t want to see around”

SQL: good comments conventions

Development MySQL

I happened upon a customer who left me in awe and admiration. The reason: excellent comments for their SQL code.

I list four major places where SQL comments are helpful. I’ll use the sakila database. It is originally scarcely commented; I’ll present it now enhanced with comments, to illustrate.

Table definitions

The CREATE TABLE statement allows for a comment, intended to describe the nature of the table:

CREATE TABLE `film_text` (
 `film_id` smallint(6) NOT NULL,
 `title` varchar(255) NOT NULL,
 `description` text,
 PRIMARY KEY (`film_id`),
 FULLTEXT KEY `idx_title_description` (`title`,`description`)
) ENGINE=MyISAM DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8 COMMENT='Reflection of `film`, used for FULLTEXT search.'

It’s too bad the comment’s max length is 60 characters, though. However, it’s a very powerful field.

Column definitions

One may comment particular columns: Continue reading » “SQL: good comments conventions”

SQL: forcing single row tables integrity

MySQL

Single row tables are used in various cases. Such tables can be used for “preferences” or “settings”; for managing counters (e.g. summary tables), for general-purpose administration tasks (e.g. heartbeat table) etc.

The problem with single row tables is that, well, they must have s single row. And the question is: how can you force them to have just one row?

The half-baked solution

The common solution is to create a PRIMARY KEY and always use the same value for that key. In addition, using REPLACE or INSERT INTO ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE helps out in updating the row. For example:

CREATE TABLE heartbeat (
 id int NOT NULL PRIMARY KEY,
 ts datetime NOT NULL
 );

The above table definition is taken from mk-heartbeat. It should be noted that mk-heartbeat in itself does not require that the table has a single row, so it is not the target of this post. I’m taking the above table definition as a very simple example.

So, we assume we want this table to have a single row, for whatever reasons we have. We would usually do:

REPLACE INTO heartbeat (id, ts) VALUES (1, NOW());

or

INSERT INTO heartbeat (id, ts) VALUES (1, NOW()) ON DUPLICATE KEY UPDATE ts = NOW();

Why is the above a “half baked solution”? Because it is up to the application to make sure it reuses the same PRIMARY KEY value. There is nothing in the database to prevent the following: Continue reading » “SQL: forcing single row tables integrity”

Personal observation: more migrations from MyISAM to InnoDB

MySQL

I’m evidencing an increase in the planning, confidence & execution for MyISAM to InnoDB migration.

How much can a single consultant observe? I agree Oracle should not go to PR based on my experience. But I find that:

  • More companies are now familiar with InnoDB than there used to.
  • More companies are interested in migration to InnoDB than there used to.
  • More companies feel such migration to be safe.
  • More companies start up with an InnoDB based solution than with a MyISAM based solution.

This is the way I see it. No doubt, the Oracle/Sun deal made its impact. The fact that InnoDB is no longer a 3rd party; the fact Oracle invests in InnoDB and no other engine (Falcon is down, no real development on MyISAM); the fact InnoDB is to be the default engine: all these put companies at ease with migration.

Continue reading » “Personal observation: more migrations from MyISAM to InnoDB”

Verifying GROUP_CONCAT limit without using variables

MySQL

I have a case where I must know if group_concat_max_len is at its default value (1024), which means there are some operation I cannot work out. I’ve ranted on this here.

Normally, I would simply:

SELECT @@group_concat_max_len

However, I am using views, where session variables are not allowed. Using a stored function can do the trick, but I wanted to avoid stored routines. So here’s a very simple test case: is the current group_concat_max_len long enough or not? I’ll present the long version and the short version.

The long version

SELECT
  CHAR_LENGTH(
    GROUP_CONCAT(
      COLLATION_NAME SEPARATOR ''
    )
  )
FROM
  INFORMATION_SCHEMA.COLLATIONS;

If the result is 1024, we are in a bad shape. I happen to know that the total length of collation names is above 1800, and so it is trimmed down. Another variance of the above query would be: Continue reading » “Verifying GROUP_CONCAT limit without using variables”